| Abbott, Jim | jimgratner (0) |
| Accardo, Jeremy | sugarpam (122) |
| Adkins, James | jaybird_1981 (4) |
| Anderson, Tyler | islandsportscards (54) |
| Andrus, Elvis | Dodgerdave (13) |
| Ankiel, Rick | stlcardinalsfan (22) |
| Arencibia, J.P. | jaybird_1981 (3) |
| Aybar, Erick | islandsportscards (0) |
| Bagwell, Jeff | 5toosweet (56) |
| Bailey, Andrew | andrewhoya (177) |
| Bailey, Ed | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Bay, Jason | ldj4440 (96) |
| Belt, Brandon | wenjiesf (5) |
| Bench, Johnny | griffey0369 (0), Jamesngin (198) |
| Biggio, Craig | Biggiofn7 (0) |
| Blyleven, Bert | SWOWannabe (9) |
| Boer, Madison | islandsportscards (13) |
| Boggs, Mitchell | stlcardinalsfan (6) |
| Boggs, Wade | jimgratner (42) |
| Boone, Bret | cpalmerfan (221) |
| Borbon, Julio | jaybird_1981 (5) |
| Borders, Pat | sugarpam (147) |
| Brabender, Gene | souperman79 (5) |
| Braun, Ryan J. | littlea61580 (0), souperman79 (0), thetopdoginla (0) |
| Bridges, Tommy | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Brito, Bernardo | DaClyde (38) |
| Bruce, Jay | CincinnatiKelly (50) |
| Buehrle, Mark | whitesoxfan60629 (59) |
| Bumgarner, Madison | wenjiesf (0) |
| Burke, Chris | jaybird_1981 (4) |
| Cabrera, Miguel | TheCardBandit (41) |
| Cain, Matt | wenjiesf (1) |
| Cantwell, Ben | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Cardinals, St. Louis | stlcardinalsfan (15) |
| Carpenter, Matt | stlcardinalsfan (3) |
| Chambers, Adron | stlcardinalsfan (6) |
| Chase, Shaun | islandsportscards (0) |
| Cianfrocco, Archi | K2737 (14) |
| Clapp, Stubby | stlcardinalsfan (1) |
| Clark, Will | Whoa2323 (344) |
| Clemens, Roger | jimgratner (47) |
| Cockrell, Alan | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Coghlan, Chris | K2737 (67) |
| Craig, Allen | stlcardinalsfan (12) |
| Crawford, Brandon | wenjiesf (5) |
| Cuddyer, Michael | twinsSamuelson (0) |
| Davis, Eric | Biggiofn7 (2) |
| Davis, Ike | mattconn (19) |
| DeLucia, Richard | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Descalso, Daniel | stlcardinalsfan (10) |
| Dickey, R.A. | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| DiFelice, Mike | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| DiMaggio, Joe | mikeF26 (0) |
| Doerr, Bobby | islandsportscards (0) |
| Dozier, Brian | mkhawk21 (23), twinsvikings31 (0) |
| Drew, J.D. | stlcardinalsfan (40) |
| Duda, Lucas | mattconn (0) |
| Edmonds, Jim | stlcardinalsfan (76) |
| Fielder, Prince | TheCardBandit (106) |
| Figgins, Chone | islandsportscards (0) |
| Florimon, Pedro | twinsvikings31 (0) |
| Freeman, Freddie | Clemson2012 (0), Sportsfanatic10 (22), wenjiesf (0) |
| Freese, David | dcehmka (1), stlcardinalsfan (7) |
| Furcal, Rafael | stlcardinalsfan (9) |
| Gantner, Jim | jimgratner (8) |
| Garcia, Jaime | stlcardinalsfan (15) |
| Garner, Phil | jaybird_1981 (1) |
| Glavine, Tom | jimgratner (13) |
| Gonzalez, Juan | Baseballfan1977 (273) |
| Griffey Jr., Ken | dpetty21 (50), griffey0369 (4), jimgratner (24), Vintage954 (403) |
| Guardado, Eddie | twinsvikings31 (0) |
| Guerrero, Vladimir | andrewcstein (2788), dcehmka (7), Greenevansj (106), Howard (2497) |
| Gwynn, Tony | jimgratner (35) |
| Hamilton, Billy | DaClyde (5) |
| Havens, Reese | mattconn (1) |
| Headley, Chase | jaybird_1981 (3) |
| Heflin, Bronson | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Helton, Todd | jaybird_1981 (46) |
| Henderson, Dave | DaClyde (244) |
| Henderson, Rickey | jimgratner (37) |
| Hendriks, Liam | BrewCrew06 (18) |
| Hernandez, Felix | islandsportscards (0) |
| Heyward, Jason | twinsvikings31 (29) |
| Hochevar, Luke | jaybird_1981 (11) |
| Holliday, Matt | griffyes (0) |
| Honeycutt, Rick | jaybird_1981 (1) |
| Hosmer, Eric | ajw9356 (23), Cards4ever82 (5) |
| Howard, Steve | DaClyde (20) |
| Howitt, Dann | DaClyde (32) |
| Hudson, Dan | AbwsAgain (1) |
| Hudson, Luke | jaybird_1981 (2) |
| Hunter, Torii | twinsSamuelson (34) |
| Hutchison, Drew | sugarpam (137) |
| Iorg, Eli | jaybird_1981 (3) |
| Jay, Jon | stlcardinalsfan (12) |
| Jeter, Derek | bakemeister52 (777), mess0312 (55), yankscards (78) |
| Johnson, Randy | jimgratner (10), sepul1 (149) |
| Jones, Chipper | mdubjdub (8) |
| Jordan, Brian | stlcardinalsfan (17) |
| Joyner, Wally | ryanloun (712) |
| Kaline, Al | jaybird_1981 (63) |
| Kelly, Joe | stlcardinalsfan (3) |
| Kelly, Roberto | DaClyde (354) |
| Kemp, Matt | Bryant #88 (51) |
| Kendall, Jason | JKC (1724) |
| Kimbrel, Craig | Sportsfanatic10 (13), wenjiesf (1) |
| Konerko, Paul | cpalmerfan (182), Djameson79 (258), whitesoxfan60629 (147) |
| Kubel, Jason | twinsvikings31 (0) |
| Lankford, Ray | stlcardinalsfan (47) |
| Lawrie, Brett | twinsvikings31 (0) |
| Lincecum, Tim | wenjiesf (2) |
| Lincoln, Mike | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Lucroy, Jonathan | souperman79 (10) |
| Lynn, Lance | stlcardinalsfan (6) |
| Maddux, Greg | jimgratner (20) |
| Markakis, Nick | tosdesserts (306) |
| Marte, Starling | alhill37 (1), jimgratner (32) |
| Martinez, Edgar | cpalmerfan (308) |
| Mauer, Joe | twinsvikings31 (4) |
| May, Trevor | PhilliesFan25 (9) |
| McClain, Joe | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| McCutchen, Andrew | Dcseam (0), JKC (16), tmbj1 (0) |
| McGee, Willie | stlcardinalsfan (33) |
| McGough, Scott | islandsportscards (12) |
| McGowan, Dustin | sugarpam (150) |
| McGriff, Fred | Djameson79 (7) |
| McGwire, Mark | jimgratner (25) |
| McMichael, Gregory | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Meulens, Hensley | DaClyde (128) |
| Moen, Kellen | islandsportscards (5) |
| Molitor, Paul | souperman79 (3) |
| Morneau, Justin | twinsvikings31 (37) |
| Morrison, Logan | K2737 (37) |
| Motte, Jason | stlcardinalsfan (20) |
| Munson, Thurman | mikeydcalgary (44) |
| Murphy, David | sa22 (335) |
| Ojeda, Augie | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Ordonez, Magglio | tutall (644) |
| Parmelee, Chris | BrewCrew06 (5) |
| Piazza, Mike | jimgratner (8), jrl1828 (55) |
| Polanco, Placido | stlcardinalsfan (5) |
| Posey, Buster | wenjiesf (8) |
| Presley, Alex | DaClyde (11) |
| Presley, Jim | DaClyde (86) |
| Presley, Kirk | DaClyde (18) |
| Pressley, Josh | DaClyde (7) |
| Pressly, Ryan | DaClyde (10) |
| Puckett, Kirby | jimgratner (43), mkhawk21 (136), sobersoul (0) |
| Pujols, Albert | ajw9356 (23), dcehmka (20), jwgreen68 (792), nickx0707 (0) |
| Ramirez, Manny | dpetty21 (54) |
| Randa, Joe | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Renteria, Edgar | stlcardinalsfan (14) |
| Revere, Ben | BrewCrew06 (17) |
| Reyes, Jose | mattconn (0) |
| Reynolds, Don | islandsportscards (0) |
| Rhodes, Karl | DaClyde (279) |
| Ripken, Cal Jr. | jimgratner (9) |
| Rodriguez, Alex | arodfan3 (732), jimgratner (9) |
| Rose, Pete | jimgratner (67) |
| Ryan, Nolan | griffey0369 (0), jimgratner (113), nolan ryan fan (19) |
| Sandberg, Ryne | bballkm32 (336), jimgratner (29) |
| Sanders, Deion | dpetty21 (2) |
| Sandoval, Pablo | wenjiesf (5) |
| Santana, Johan | johan29lhp (652) |
| Santo, Ron | DiebytheCubs (33) |
| Scherzer, Max | TheCardBandit (179) |
| Schmidt, Mike | joeylion (13) |
| Searcy, Steve | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Sheffield, Gary | Cards4ever82 (1) |
| Smith, Bud | stlcardinalsfan (9) |
| Smith, Ozzie | stlcardinalsfan (90) |
| Smith, Ray | islandsportscards (0) |
| Smithson, Mike | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Spahn, Warren | A7V (45) |
| Span, Denard | twinsvikings31 (5) |
| Stubbs, Drew | CincinnatiKelly (30) |
| Suzuki, Ichiro | islandsportscards (0) |
| Suzuki, Kurt | islandsportscards (0) |
| Swagerty, Jordan | stlcardinalsfan (2) |
| Tatis, Fernando | stlcardinalsfan (10) |
| Tejada, Ruben | mattconn (1) |
| Thigpen, Curtis | sugarpam (59) |
| Thomas, Frank | cometko (1013) |
| Trammell, Bubba | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Uecker, Bob | souperman79 (2) |
| Upton, B.J. | Clemson2012 (0), nibrugnerotto (43) |
| Upton, Justin | Cards4ever82 (9), Clemson2012 (0) |
| Valencia, Danny | twinsSamuelson (0) |
| Verlander, Justin | gladdyontherise (170), mikez1031 (335), TheCardBandit (145) |
| Votto, Joey | CincinnatiKelly (101), dlackey (0), Livin_OK (628), okredlegs (0) |
| Wainwright, Adam | stlcardinalsfan (22) |
| Walker, Neil | JKC (63) |
| Weaver, Jered | islandsportscards (0) |
| Williams, Don | jaybird_1981 (0) |
| Williams, Matt | DaClyde (540) |
| Willingham, Josh | jrl1828 (42) |
| Wilson, Brian | jones9923 (26), TheCardBandit (48) |
| Winfield, Dave | DaClyde (1127) |
| Witt, Kevin | sugarpam (118) |
| Wood, Kerry | cubsfan76 (0), jimgratner (5) |
| Wright, David | andrewcstein (787), mattconn (296), oxmav3rickxo (18) |
| Yastrzemski, Carl | yazfan71 (431) |
| Yastrzemski, Michael | yazfan71 (2) |
| Yastrzemski, Mike | yazfan71 (6) |
| Yount, Robin | bill1968 (28), souperman79 (77) |
| Zambrano, Carlos | CubsFan38 (92) |
